English Toolkit for Thorildsplans Gymnasium
Critical thinking

Classifying arguments

Levels of Intellectual Engagement chart

This chart helps you recognise how a debate is being framed, where the reasoning may go wrong and what to ask next. Use it to make sense of arguments—in class, in conversation and in the media—and to question your own thinking as carefully as you question other people’s.

For academic analysis, aim to work mainly at Levels 3–5. These levels help you develop focused questions, examine evidence and explore causes, systems and assumptions. When you encounter a Level 2 or Level 1 statement, look for a claim you can examine—if there is one—and turn it into a question you can investigate.

For example, “Schools are indoctrinating our children” becomes “What do students actually learn, and how would we know?”

The five levels at a glance

Read down the vertical axis for the five LIE levels, from 5 to 1. Read across the horizontal axis for each level’s focus, discourse style, examples and reasoning issues.

LIE levelFocusDiscourse styleExample questions / claimsCommon reasoning issues
Level 5 — Principles and assumptionsPhilosophical and reflectiveExploring ethics, values, meanings and the assumptions behind our judgments.Philosophical argument, thought experiments and dialogue that examines principlesWhat does fairness mean? When should individual freedom give way to collective welfare? Are we applying our principles consistently? · · ·
Level 4 — Systems and relationshipsAnalytical and investigativeExplaining how institutions, incentives, history and power interact to produce or maintain a problem.Causal explanation, comparative analysis and investigation of connectionsWhy does this problem exist? How do institutions, incentives and historical conditions contribute? How do these factors interact? · · ·
Level 3 — Evidence and policyPractical and evidence-basedAssessing specific claims and proposals, comparing alternatives and weighing outcomes and trade-offs.Evidence-based policy debate, comparison of proposals and evaluation of trade-offsWhich policy would address the problem? What reliable evidence supports it? What are the costs, benefits and alternatives? · · ·
Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone riskThe risk is accepting an emotionally compelling story as a complete explanation, without checking its claims or considering alternatives.Narrative and emotionally persuasiveFraming an issue through stories about threats, injustice, victims and villains. Can develop into moral or societal panics when claims are exaggerated or poorly checked.Emotionally persuasive storytelling, alarmist headlines, anecdotal generalisations and sweeping warnings“Socialism always leads to dictatorship.” “Schools are indoctrinating our children.” “This policy will destroy our way of life.” “Is your child safe at school? What they don’t want you to know.” · · ·
Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone when labels replace argumentsPersonal and tribalFocusing on people, identities, symbols and group loyalty. In social media culture wars, defending a side can replace examining the argument.Slogans, memes, ridicule, personal attacks and declarations of group loyalty“Socialists are lazy.” “Woke idiots!” “You’re only saying that because you’re one of them.” “Whose side are you on?” · · ·

The levels describe the focus of a discussion. Higher levels offer more productive starting points, not automatically better arguments. A personal story or case study can contribute useful evidence when checked and placed in context. Abstract reasoning still needs clear definitions and support. Reasoning issues can occur at any level. The quoted claims are illustrative examples, not statements of fact.

Social media culture wars: Polarised debates about social and cultural issues in which defending your side and attacking the other can take priority over understanding the issue. Misleading claims, misinformation and logical fallacies can reinforce these divisions. The topic itself is not the trap; the trap is letting group loyalty replace evidence and reasoning.

Move the discussion upward

Level 2 claim

“Socialism always leads to dictatorship.”

Level 3 or 4 question

“Which countries have adopted socialist policies, what kind of government did each have, and what other factors help explain the outcomes?”

The move is from a sweeping conclusion to a question that requires definitions, evidence and comparison. Define what you mean by socialist policies and by each type of government before comparing cases. There are many possible questions at each level; the topic examples below show other ways to investigate socialism.

Look beneath a label—if there is a claim

Level 1 statement

“Socialists are lazy.”

This describes people, not an idea.

Find the claim underneath, if there is one. The speaker might mean “welfare systems reduce people’s incentive to work”. That is a claim, and it can be tested. Ask whether this is what the speaker means rather than assuming it.

Level 3 question

“How do different welfare and tax systems affect employment, and what does the evidence show?”

There may be no claim here

“Woke idiots!”

On its own, this only expresses contempt. There is nothing to test. You can ask whether the speaker has a specific claim, but you do not have to invent an argument for them.

Try the same move with another statement from the table. If there’s no claim, say so. If there is, turn it into a specific question: what evidence would help answer it, and what might challenge your first impression?

One topic, five levels

Choose a topic to see how the discussion changes across the five levels.

Socialism

Level 5 — Principles

What makes an economy just? How should we balance equality, individual freedom and democratic control?

Level 4 — Systems

How do ownership, market competition and political institutions shape who holds economic power and who receives the wealth an economy produces?

Level 3 — Policy and evidence

Should a particular industry be publicly owned, privately owned or run by worker cooperatives? What evidence helps us compare the costs, benefits and trade-offs?

Level 2 — Narratives and framing Trap-zone risk

“Socialism always leads to dictatorship.” / “Socialism will take everything you own.” / “Capitalism will inevitably leave everyone except the rich in poverty.”

Level 1 — People and labels Trap zone

“Socialists are lazy.” / “Capitalists are greedy.”

Climate policy

Level 5 — Principles and assumptions

How should responsibility for climate action be shared between individuals, businesses and governments—and between richer and poorer countries?

Level 4 — Systems and relationships

How do energy infrastructure, business incentives and political institutions shape the choices available to households?

Level 3 — Evidence and policy

Would a carbon tax reduce emissions? How would its costs fall on different households, and what alternatives should be compared?

Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone risk

“First they make you buy an electric car; next they’ll ban meat and stop you travelling. Climate policy is about controlling your life.” / “Question this climate policy and you’re helping destroy our children’s future.”

Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone

“Eco-fascists want to run your life.” / “Climate deniers are too stupid to understand science.”

Education and race

Level 5 — Principles and assumptions

What should education aim to do when historical understanding, national identity and competing ideas of fairness come into tension?

Level 4 — Systems and relationships

How do funding, housing patterns and curriculum decisions interact to shape educational opportunities?

Level 3 — Evidence and policy

What should a particular history curriculum include, and what evidence helps us assess its accuracy and effects on learning?

Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone risk

“Look at this teacher’s video. Schools are teaching children to hate their country and feel guilty for being white.” / “One parent challenged this lesson. They’re trying to erase the history of racism from our schools.”

Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone

“Woke teachers are brainwashing our kids.” / “Those parents are just racists.”

Gender and inclusion

Level 5 — Principles and assumptions

How should institutions balance inclusion, fairness and individual rights when these principles conflict?

Level 4 — Systems and relationships

How do institutional rules and social expectations affect access and participation for different groups?

Level 3 — Evidence and policy

What eligibility rules should a particular sporting competition adopt? What evidence and trade-offs are relevant?

Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone risk

“Let trans women compete and women’s sport will disappear.” / “Anyone who questions the eligibility rules hates trans people.”

Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone

“Anyone supporting trans rights is a groomer.” / “Anyone questioning this policy is a fascist.”

Free speech

Level 5 — Principles and assumptions

When, if ever, should freedom of expression be limited to protect others from harm?

Level 4 — Systems and relationships

How do platform business models and recommendation systems influence which voices are amplified or restricted?

Level 3 — Evidence and policy

What moderation rules should a platform use, and how should users be able to appeal a decision?

Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone risk

“They banned this conservative account. That proves Big Tech is silencing everyone who disagrees with the left.” / “Let this speaker on campus and hate will take over our university.”

Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone

“Woke snowflakes can’t handle the truth.” / “You only care about free speech because you want to spread hate.”

Public health

Level 5 — Principles and assumptions

When is it justified to limit individual choice to protect the health of others?

Level 4 — Systems and relationships

How do access to healthcare, working conditions and trust in institutions affect the success of public-health measures?

Level 3 — Evidence and policy

Would a proposed health measure achieve its aim? What do the evidence, risks and practical costs show?

Level 2 — Narratives and framingIncludes moral and societal panicsTrap-zone risk

“They changed their advice again. That proves they were lying all along.” / “Someone got ill after a vaccine, so the vaccine must have caused it.”

Level 1 — People, identity and labelsIncludes social media culture warsTrap zone

“You took the vaccine? You’re a sheep.” / “You’re asking questions? You’re an anti-science conspiracy nut.”

The wording and reasoning matter. A specific threat supported by evidence can be worth investigating; calling someone a name tells us little about whether their argument is sound.

What changes as you move down?

Read the examples again, from Level 5 to Level 1. What happens to the questions being asked, the language being used and the room for disagreement?

A few things to notice

In these examples, the focus moves from principles and systems to particular policies, then to sweeping warnings and personal labels. The language becomes more absolute, and there is less room to consider alternatives.

A warning may raise a real concern, but it still needs clear definitions and evidence. An insult tells us little about whether an idea is sound. Asking “What do you mean?”, “How do you know?” or “Under what conditions?” can help reopen the discussion.

This is a pattern in these examples, rather than a rule that every discussion follows. Questions about principles also need evidence and careful reasoning.

Check the argument—and yourself

At every level, look at the argument, check its quality and question your own response.

1. Understand the argument

Elements of reasoning: Purpose · Question · Information · Inferences · Assumptions · Concepts · Point of view · Implications

What is the claim? What evidence, assumptions and perspective support it? What follows if we accept it?

Check the sources too

Who produced the information, and what is their purpose? Do they have relevant expertise and show where their evidence comes from? Can you trace a quotation, statistic or video back to its original context? Do independent sources support the claim, or are they repeating the same story?

Use the Source evaluation guide to check accuracy, bias and the evidence behind a claim →

2. Check its quality

Intellectual standards: Clarity · Accuracy · Precision · Relevance · Depth · Breadth · Logic · Significance · Completeness · Fairness

Is the argument clear, accurate and relevant? Does its reasoning hold together? Does it address complexity and represent other perspectives fairly?

What can you reasonably conclude from the evidence you have—and what are you still unsure about?

3. Check yourself

Intellectual traits: Humility · Autonomy · Integrity · Courage · Perseverance · Confidence in reason · Empathy · Fair-mindedness

Am I applying the same standards to my own side? Can I explain the opposing view fairly? What would make me change my mind?

Being uncertain does not mean every view is equally convincing. Explain why your conclusion is reasonable, and stay willing to reconsider it.

Use this in a real discussion

  1. Spot when people are talking past each other: One person asks, “Is the claim supported by evidence?” while another responds, “Whose side are you on?” One is examining whether the claim is true; the other is demanding loyalty.
  2. Recognise a trap: Is an emotionally powerful story or personal attack replacing evidence?
  3. Ask better questions: Can you clarify the claim, check the source or examine an assumption?
  4. Check your own reactions: Are you applying the same standards to arguments you like and arguments you dislike?

Adapted from the Paul–Elder approach presented by the Foundation for Critical Thinking. The three steps are a classroom adaptation; the key terms come from its elements, standards and intellectual traits.

Example: